Toddy Cold Brew Recipe: Step-by-Step Instructions

Toddy Cold Brew recipe ideas are taking the internet by storm. In this article, we’ll explore how you can make your own delicious Toddy coffee at home.
Samanta Fryer
Samanta Fryer
Samanta Fryer is our senior editor and content writer, at CoffeeVibe. Apart from writing and reading, she’s fond of the coffee brewing process and enjoys tasting new coffe read more
Reviewed By
Ryan Hendricks
Ryan Hendricks
Ryan Hendricks is our tester, who puts products through their paces. He used to be a barista and is now a full-time coffee enthusiast. He’s always testing out new gadgets, read more
Last updated: December 14, 2022
CoffeeVibe is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Cold brew coffee dates back to the 1600s, but it has seen a rapid increase in popularity over the last decade. Cold brew coffee is less bitter compared to when it is made with hot water, and it also offers some great benefits including that it may lift your mood and could boost your metabolism.

Unfortunately, many people find making cold brew a little fiddly and this is where a Toddy Cold Brew can provide a great solution. Toddy Cold Brew systems use a unique extraction process to ensure a full bodied and flavorful cup of coffee. So, in this article, we’ll explore how to use this type of system and the best Toddy Cold Brew recipe variations.

How to use Toddy Cold Brew System

Toddy Cold Brew Recipe: Step-by-Step Instructions

A Toddy Cold Brew system is a little different than traditional types of coffee makers, so you will need some additional tools. These include:

  • A brewing container
  • Glass decanter with lid
  • Brewing handle
  • Rubber stopper
  • Toddy Filter

There are numerous benefits of cold brew coffee, so you need to be prepared for it to take time. You can’t simply set up a coffee maker and enjoy a cup five minutes later. However, once you master the Toddy Cold Brew system, you’re sure to see it’s well worth the wait.

The first step is to put the stopper in the bottom of the Toddy cold brew maker. The stopper goes in from the outside and it needs to be properly inserted. Wet one of your paper filters and put it into the bottom of the coffee maker. Add half of the coffee grounds and water into the container, try using a circular motion to help prevent the beans sticking to the filter. Add the remaining coffee and water using a spoon to ensure the coffee is fully submerged. Do this gently, as pressing down on the beans can cause clumping.

Cover the brew maker and allow it to steep for 12 to 24 hours at room temperature. After this time, remove the rubber stopper and allow the coffee to run into the decanter. You can then sweeten your cold brew coffee to taste.

The Recipe Variations

While a cold brew coffee can be a great pick me up, once you master your system, you’re likely to want to master Toddy Cold Brew recipe variations. Fortunately, cold brew coffee is extremely versatile and you can make it into some superb beverages, particularly if you’re using the best coffee beans.

Cafe au Lait:

Toddy Cold Brew Recipe: Step-by-Step Instructions

This is a traditional coffee recipe, with a name that simply translates into coffee with milk in French. You’ll need two ounces of cold brew coffee, six ounces of milk and a little cinnamon. Heat your cold brew coffee concentrate with the milk in a steaming pitcher. Be sure not to allow it to boil. You can then pour it into your mug and dust with a little cinnamon.

Toddy Frappe:

Toddy Cold Brew Recipe: Step-by-Step Instructions

If you want to enjoy an adult milkshake, this Toddy Frappe is a great choice. While it isn’t for the calorie conscious, this is certainly great as an occasional treat. You’ll need six ounces of cold brew, two ounces of condensed milk, ice and optional whipped cream.

Add the coffee, milk and ice to your blender and blend until the mixture is smooth. Pour into a tall chilled glass and top with the whipped cream.

Toddy Thai Iced Coffee:

Toddy Cold Brew Recipe: Step-by-Step Instructions

This is a spin on a conventional chai latte, which is worthy of being called a toddy commercial cold brew recipe. It is brewed with spices, making it appeal to coffee and tea drinkers. You’ll need four ounces of cold brew, two ounces of half and half, ice and ¼ teaspoon of cardamom.

Stir the cold brew together with the half and half and cardamom. Fill a large, tall glass with ice and pour the mixture over.

Tipsy Cold Brew and Tonic:

Toddy Cold Brew Recipe: Step-by-Step Instructions

If you fancy an adult drink that is a delicious choice for a relaxing evening, try the tipsy cold brew and tonic. You’ll need two ounces of cold brew, two ounces of gin, four ounces of tonic water and ¼ ounce of simple syrup. You’ll also need ice, a lemon wedge and a sprig of rosemary for garnish.

Blend the gin and simple syrup over ice in a cocktail shaker. Place ice into a glass and strain the gin and sugar mixture into the glass, add the tonic. Now, gently pour the cold brew into the glass. It should float on the top of the tonic to create a pretty, layered drink. Garnish with the lemon wedge and rosemary.


How much can a Toddy brewing container hold?

Toddy brewing containers are designed to hold one point of coffee and nine cups of water. This means that while you need to wait 12 to 24 hours for the coffee to brew, you’ll have more than enough for all your Toddy Cold Brew recipe ideas.

How often do you need to replace a Toddy filter?

The Toddy felt filters are available in replacement bags of two and Toddy recommends replacing them every three months or 10 to 12 uses, whichever occurs first.

How long can you store Toddy Cold Brew?

Although it takes up to 24 hours to create the smooth, rich coffee concentrate, Toddy Cold Brew can stay fresh for up to two weeks in the refrigerator.

Final thoughts

Cold brew is a great way to make coffee concentrate that is a key ingredient in many Toddy cold brew recipe ideas. Once you understand the basics of making Toddy cold brew, you may be surprised at the number of ways you can use your coffee in cold drinks, hot beverages and even baking.

After you master making your cold brew recipes, you can harness the benefits of this type of coffee, so you can enjoy a great brew and the numerous potential health benefits.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *